About Us
What do our guests think?
Old Salem Cafe is pleased to announce that we took 1st place as the "Best All Around Restaurant", 1st Place for "Best Wait Staff", 2nd Place for "Girls Night Out Spot", 2nd Place for "Best Breakfast", 2nd Place for "Take Out", 2nd Place for "Place for a Cocktail", 3rd place for "Best Outdoor Seating", and tied for 3rd Place for "Best Business Lunch". This survey included restaurants in Marshall, The Plains, Haymarket, and New Baltimore. Thanks to all of those who voted and we look forward to continue providing exceptional service to the community.
Who we are
The Old Salem Cafe is open 7 days a week and offers a great assortment of dining options. Our menu consists of appetizers that include wings to shrimp and frog legs. Various soups and salads, hot and cold sandwiches, and daily specials. Dinner items include steak, liver and onions, fried oysters, and catfish. Be sure to check out our menu link for a full list!